News

15 Extremely Overpriced Cars

by:

Some car models cost much more at the dealership than the manufacturer’s suggested retail price (MSRP).

According to a recent iSeeCars study, the average new car will cost as much as 7.2 percent above the manufacturer’s recommended price. Generally, consumers want to stay close to the MSRP when purchasing a new vehicle — exceeding the MSRP means you’re paying unnecessary markup at the dealer!

Here’s a selection of 15 extremely overpriced cars.

1. Porsche Taycan (sedan)

porsche taycan
Photo Credit: Porsche.

The Porsche Taycan sedan, priced around $137,729, is priced a whopping 23.1% above MSRP on average, making it the second most overpriced new vehicle after the MINI Cooper Hardtop’s 25.5%.

As Porsche’s electric sedan, the Taycan commands premium pricing despite improved EV supply. Why?

Taycan combines the reflexes and acceleration of a sports car and packs up to 1019 horsepower. The 2025 model has a driving range of up to 340 miles. It has a premium price for top specs.

2. Chevrolet Camaro

2024 Chevrolet Camaro SS Collector’s Edition
Photo Credit: Chevrolet.

While not a luxury vehicle, the Chevrolet Camaro sports car surprisingly ranks among the most overpriced models at $36,900, about 22.3% above MSRP in markets like Norfolk, VA. Its muscle car appeal allows dealers to mark it up significantly.

The Camaro is available as a coupe or soft-top convertible with a 335-hp V6 or a 455-hp V8 engine. There’s also a more powerful ZL1 with a 650-horsepower engine. The fact that the Challenger and Mustang are taking different paths could also explain why they command such a premium.

3. Porsche Cayenne

Porsche Cayenne
Photo Credit: Porsche.

The popular Porsche Cayenne SUV ranks 3rd most overpriced at $105,500, typically 21.9% above sticker price on average. In markets like Los Angeles, the midsize two-row SUV is marked up over 31% thanks to high demand for the luxury SUV.

Cayenne has established itself as the de facto yardstick for driving pleasure, so it’s no surprise it commands a premium price. All variants boast delicate handling, athleticism, and lightweightness.

4. Cadillac CT5-V

2025 Cadillac CT5-V
Photo Credit: Cadillac.

The high-performance Cadillac CT5-V sedan is around $67,200, 20% over the MSRP, making it one of the most marked-up mainstream luxury vehicles.

The CT5-V is at the summit of General Motors’ engineering, with crisp handling and the best traction control system the industry offers. The Cadillac is powered by a hearty 668-hp V-8.

5. Porsche 718 Boxster

Porsche 718 Boxster
Photo Credit: Depositphotos.

Another in-demand Porsche model, the Porsche 718 Boxster convertible sports car, commands a 19.9% premium over MSRP. The mid-engined performance model boasts an exceptionally balanced chassis and crisp handling.

6. Porsche 718 Cayman

Porsche 718 Cayman S
Photo Credit: Porsche.

The coupe version of the 718, the Cayman, is priced 18.9% above the sticker on average at $105,910.

Porsche has significant pricing leverage due to the benchmarks it has set for sports cars—surgically precise handling, exceptional steering, and awesome power, even for the base turbocharged four-cylinder engine.

7. MINI Countryman

2021 MINI Countryman
Photo Credit: BMW Group.

According to the data, the MINI Countryman surprisingly goes for 18.7% over MSRP at $40,757 as a small premium crossover. But despite the mini and small connotations, the SUV boasts a more spacious interior. And while the styling cues do not veer off too much from the familiar, the MINI Countryman adds a touch of modernity.

8. MINI Clubman

MINI Clubman
Photo Credit: Depositphotos.

The MINI Clubman wagon variant is also highly overpriced at around $43,200, 18.7% above its MSRP. The Clubman’s unique selling point is its luscious exterior design, much larger cargo area, and exciting acceleration. It also inherits the fun driving characteristics for which the MINI lineup is known and incredible customization options.

9. Toyota Corolla Cross Hybrid

Toyota Corolla Cross Hybrid
Photo Credit: Depositphotos.

An unexpected entry, the Toyota Corolla Cross Hybrid small crossover is marked up 19.4% over sticker despite being a mainstream, non-luxury vehicle. Many people may question the combination of a Toyota and the $33,719 premium.

But the Corolla is synonymous with efficiency, practicality, and value. The model also offers a standard all-wheel drive, increased cargo room, and a better ride height than its sedan sibling.

10. Mercedes-Benz GLE

Mercedes-Benz GLE
Photo Credit: Depositphotos.

The midsize GLE SUV represents Mercedes’ premium pricing power, going for around $82,300, which represents 18.6% above its MSRP on average. But unlike Toyota, this isn’t unexpected. The Mercedes-Benz GLE is a head turner, thanks to the facelift, and gets more off-road creds than comparable SUVs when optioned with air suspension.

11. Ford Maverick

Ford Maverick
Photo Credit: Ford.

As an affordable compact pickup, the Ford Maverick ranks among the highest markups at approximately $33,000, 18.2% over MSRP, due to limited supply.

While the Maverick may not hold a candle to the F-150, it has a stout payload and towing capability. Its cabin is generously equipped and feels more upscale.

12. BMW X3 M

BMW X3 M
Photo Credit: BMW Group.

The high-performance X3 M SUV from BMW can demand around $90,057, which represents a 19.4% premium according to the data, reflecting BMW’s luxury brand pricing.

The model has a twin-turbocharged six-cylinder engine generating up to 503 horses for fun riding. All around, the X3 has attractive materials and offers a luxury experience.

13. Lexus LS 500

Lexus LS 500
Photo Credit: Lexus.

The flagship Lexus LS 500 luxury sedan sells for around $94,900, which is 18.6% over the sticker price on average for the brand’s highest model.

The LS 500 combines luxury and performance, which has made it popular in the market. Thanks to a 416-horsepower turbocharged V-6, its cabin is whisper-quiet, and its acceleration is smooth.

14. Mitsubishi Mirage G4

Mitsubishi Mirage G4
Photo Credit: Mitsubishi.

An entry-level sedan like the Mirage G4 being marked up at around $24,562, which is 33% over MSRP in Austin, TX, highlights the extremes some dealers are willing to go to. But why the Mirage G4?

The manufacturer boasts of its class-leading fuel economy of a combined 37 MPG, which makes it a good package when combined with good performance. The Mirage G4 seats five adults and is one of the most affordable sedans on the market.

15. Genesis GV80

Genesis GV80
Photo Credit: Genesis.

The Genesis GV80 midsize luxury SUV represents the pricing power of the Genesis brand at $70,000, which is 17.4% over MSRP. It oozes sophistication with a refined exterior, including a G-matrix crest grill and two-line LED lamps.

The GV80 boasts innovative technology that extends to the passengers. Hidden beneath the sleek skin is either a standard turbo four-cylinder with a good punch or the optional twin-turbo V-6 for more performance. The GV80 is the stuff of class, attracting a crowd that won’t mind the premium pricing.

The study shows that while luxury brands can command higher markups, some mainstream models are incredibly overpriced due to limited inventory and high demand. Sports cars and SUVs tend to be the worst offenders for extreme markups.

View the iseecars study here

DIVE DEEPER...